The Disabilities Leadership Council recently received a fascinating article written by one of our members, Educational Consultant, Heidi Reichel. The article highlights some of the problems that result from giving special education students accommodations in schools. It also addresses some of the difficulties that special education students face once they leave high school and prepare to enter the workforce. The article is found below.
Toward the close of the last school year there were news articles about special education students who were ‘graduating’ school with IEP ‘Diplomas’ and not prepared for competitive employment. This should not have come as a surprise to anyone. Those students were on alternative assessment. They did not have to sit for any of the State tests that typical students take. They did not do the same coursework. There is no disputing the fact that, those students were not being prepared to lead self-sufficient independent lives. IEP ‘Diplomas’ were not designed for students who had the potential for competitive employment. IEP ‘Diplomas’ are not high school diplomas at all, in fact, students who have received IEP ‘Diplomas’ are still eligible to continue going to high school to pursue a regular high school diploma.
The more insidious problem, however, is that many special education students (often, but not always, classified as learning disabled) are graduating school with actual high school diplomas and are not prepared either. These students passed their classes and exit exams but they did it with the help of special education accommodations such as one to one aides, tests read, scribes, directions repeated and or simplified, and extended time. Perhaps their spelling errors were not to be counted against them or perhaps they weren’t required to fill in the bubbles on Scantron answer sheets. Graduating from high school led these students to believe that they were ready for employment or higher education. Imagine their surprise (maybe I should say shock or horror) when they found that they weren’t able to read or write well enough to fill out a job application or when they could only qualify to enroll in non credit bearing remedial courses at the local community college.
I know that a lot of teachers and parents believe that giving students special education (and 504) accommodations only levels the playing field. However, that would only be true if school was a game and the goal was just to pass the tests and eventually get a diploma. School is not a game. The purpose of school is to educate students so that they have the tools necessary to become successful independent adults. Keeping students on an artificially leveled playing field denies them that opportunity.
“But these kids would never make it without accommodations. You’re setting them up to fail!” I would never set children up to fail and I don’t want others to prevent them from succeeding. What I am advocating here, is going beyond accommodating them all the way to educating them. Teach them how to read, write, fill in Scantron forms, follow instructions and pay attention all by themselves. They will not have someone at their beckon call to help them with these things once they leave high school. Even if their aspirations are low and all they want to do is drive a car, get a job, and go out on dates, they will need to have these basic skills. I have found that in over 90% of cases if students aren’t learning, then they are not being taught (appropriately for them). By the way, it doesn’t matter if a student is being taught with a ‘scientifically proven’ method. If that student isn’t learning then that method is inappropriate for that student.
Heidi Reichel is an Educational Consultant with a private practice in Huntington, N.Y. She is primarily involved in tutoring, remediation, diagnostic educational testing, and advocacy. You can contact her at (631) 423-6215 or by e-mail at Heidi1121@att.net.
Copyright 2009 by Heidi Reichel
No comments:
Post a Comment